The Federal Court of Justice has ruled that a clause in a real estate development contract is invalid if it provides that an expert selected and paid for by the developer is to declare the common property accepted, and the purchasers must authorize the expert in advance to do so. If, due to this invalid clause, there is no valid acceptance, the five-year statute of limitations for claims for defects in the common property does not begin to run—though only up to a maximum of 30 years from the date of the originally scheduled but failed acceptance. These claims cannot be deemed forfeited solely because many years have passed since the handover.
What was the case about?
In 1999, a real estate developer built a residential complex and entered into development agreements with the buyers. The contract stipulated that the inspection of the common property was to be conducted by an expert selected and paid for by the developer; the buyers had already authorized this expert to do so in the contract. In 2001, the developer handed over the common property; an expert conducted two inspections and recorded in reports that the inspected areas were free of technical defects.
In the years that followed, the buyers reported various defects—initially with the heating system, and later with the roof and the facade—which the developer remedied in each instance. In 2021, approximately 20 years after the handover, the plaintiff homeowners’ association commissioned another expert assessment. The report identified additional defects in the roof and facade cladding that had not previously been reported, with the cost of repairing them estimated at approximately 820,000 euros. The condominium owners adopted the claims by resolution and unsuccessfully demanded that the developer remedy the defects. The developer invoked the statute of limitations and forfeiture.
The Munich I Regional Court dismissed the lawsuit on the grounds of forfeiture. The Munich Higher Regional Court upheld this decision by order. The Federal Court of Justice overturned this decision and remanded the case.
Why was the acceptance clause invalid?
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) reaffirms its previous case law: A clause stipulating that an expert selected and paid for by the developer inspects and approves the common property unreasonably disadvantages the purchasers within the meaning of Section 9(1) of the German Standard Terms and Conditions Act (AGB-Gesetz) (the predecessor provision to the current Section 307 of the German Civil Code (BGB), which is still applicable here). The reason: Such an expert has a close relationship with the developer and may not assess the property’s readiness for acceptance in a neutral manner.
Crucially, the clause completely deprives the purchasers of their statutory right under § 640(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) to decide for themselves on acceptance by granting a power of attorney in the contract. Such a provision deviates significantly from the fundamental principles of the law without adequately taking the purchasers’ interests into account. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) thus reaffirms its position from earlier decisions regarding comparable clauses.
When does the statute of limitations begin if acceptance fails?
Because the clause was invalid, the expert could not declare a valid acceptance on behalf of the purchasers. Thus, there was no acceptance of the common property. This has implications for the statute of limitations: According to Section 634a(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB), the five-year statute of limitations for claims for defects in the common property (Sections 633 et seq. BGB, as in effect on January 1, 2002) does not begin to run until acceptance has taken place. Without a valid acceptance, the period does not begin—the purchasers’ claims were therefore not barred by the statute of limitations in the case at hand, even though approximately 20 years had elapsed between the handover and the assertion of the claims.
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) also emphasizes that, in good faith, the developer cannot argue that the purchasers’ claim for defects is already barred by the general ten-year statute of limitations under Section 199(4) of the German Civil Code (BGB). Anyone who uses an invalid acceptance clause may not derive any advantage from its consequences.
Is there a time limit on claims for defects?
Yes. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) confirms an upper limit already established in an earlier decision: Claims for defects in common property cannot be asserted indefinitely despite the lack of acceptance, but only within 30 years from the date on which acceptance failed due to the invalid clause. This time limit results from a supplementary interpretation of the contract and serves the interest of legal certainty, without completely relieving the developer of the consequences of its own invalid contract drafting.
In the case at hand, the failed acceptance took place in 2001, and the claims were asserted in 2021—well within the 30-year statute of limitations. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) also points out that it is up to the developer to set the statute of limitations in motion: After rectifying defects, the developer may demand acceptance from the purchaser at any time, since the purchaser is obligated under Section 640(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) to accept a work that has been completed in accordance with the contract.
When does tacit acceptance still apply?
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) reiterates its case law, according to which implied (tacit) acceptance is generally ruled out if the purchasers were led to believe that acceptance was no longer necessary because an expert inspection had already been conducted. In such cases, mere commencement of use, utilization, and full payment are not sufficient to demonstrate the purchasers’ intent to accept the goods.
According to the ruling, however, implied acceptance may be considered if, from the developer’s perspective, the purchasers recognized—or at least anticipated—that the agreed-upon formal acceptance had failed, and their conduct can nevertheless be interpreted as an expression of their intent to accept. In the case at hand, however, there was no factual basis for this: Nothing indicated that the purchasers had recognized or should have recognized that the agreed-upon acceptance had failed.
Why did the Federal Court of Justice rule against forfeiture?
The Court of Appeals had held that the claims for defects were barred because 20 years had elapsed between the transfer of ownership and the assertion of the claims (time factor) and because the purchasers had, through multiple inspections for defects, indicated that they had made a final assessment of the item (circumstantial factor). The Federal Court of Justice disagrees.
On the one hand, the mere passage of time is not sufficient; forfeiture is not governed by rigid deadlines. On the other hand, the developer could not conclude from the earlier complaint regarding certain defects (such as those in the heating system or specific areas of the roof and facade) that the purchasers would no longer assert claims regarding other defects of which they were unaware at the time. The fact that purchasers are unaware of certain defects and therefore do not report them is one of the typical risks borne by the developer—not the purchaser. Nor was the developer permitted to develop a legitimate expectation that no valid acceptance had taken place and that claims were therefore not yet barred by the statute of limitations, if there is no evidence that the purchasers were aware of this.
Finally, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) clarifies: A real estate developer who uses a clause that is unreasonably disadvantageous is acting in bad faith and cannot simultaneously argue that the use of such a clause was customary at the time the contract was drafted. This fact does not alter the fact that the risk of the clause being invalid lies with the party using it.
Practical Conclusions
For real estate developers, the ruling means that acceptance clauses granting a property appraiser—selected and paid for by the developer—the authority to accept the common property are invalid. Anyone who has used such clauses must expect that the statute of limitations on claims for defects will not begin until an actually valid acceptance has taken place—in extreme cases, therefore, only decades after handover, but no later than 30 years after the failed acceptance. Developers can limit this risk by actively demanding a valid acceptance from the purchaser or the condominium owners’ association after defects have been remedied.
For condominium owners’ associations and purchasers, the ruling shows that an invalid acceptance clause in the developer’s contract can still secure their claims for defects even after many years—the mere passage of 20 years does not automatically result in forfeiture. However, documentation remains crucial: Anyone invoking a failed acceptance should be able to prove that neither a valid formal acceptance nor a tacit acceptance took place.
Source: Federal Court of Justice (BGH), Judgment of October 15, 2026, Case No.: VII ZR 4/24
Jochen Mittenzwey
Attorney
Certified Specialist in Construction and Architectural Law
mittenzwey@mo45.de