A photo of attorney Jochen Mittenzwey and the Mo45 Legal Berlin logo
06.
November

The Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg has ruled that the “Reinickendorfer Straße” social preservation ordinance is lawful. Neither procedural flaws in the drafting process nor substantive errors in the delineation of the area or the underlying study were sufficient to overturn the ordinance. For property owners in preservation zones, this means that the hurdles to successfully challenging such ordinances remain high.

What was the case about?

A property owner in Berlin-Mitte challenged the “Reinickendorfer Straße” Social Preservation Ordinance dated October 19, 2021. Pursuant to Section 172(1), first sentence, No. 2 of the German Building Code (BauGB), this ordinance requires a permit for the demolition, alteration, or change of use of structures if such actions could alter the composition of the resident population. The same Senate had previously declared a predecessor ordinance from 2018 invalid because the district had erroneously based it on survey results for a different area.

The owner raised objections regarding both procedural and substantive issues. On procedural grounds, she objected, among other things, to discrepancies between the resolution passed by the district council and the version subsequently published, as well as the absence of the district mayor’s signature. On substantive grounds, she considered the underlying study to be inadequate, particularly due to the low response rate in the household survey.

What was the court's ruling on the procedural objections?

The court did not view the provision regarding the expiration of the old ordinance—which had been inserted retroactively—as an impermissible substantive amendment, but merely as a clarification; the old ordinance would have expired automatically in any case. Nor did the absence of the district mayor’s signature on the draft resolution render it invalid: in the court’s view, such a violation of the rules of procedure of the district council does not affect any statutory provisions or membership rights. A formal statement of reasons, as required for a zoning plan, is not mandated for a preservation ordinance in any case.

How strictly does the court review the substantive justification?

In the Senate’s view, the enactment of a social preservation ordinance constitutes a planning decision that, however, requires only a limited balancing of interests. The primary focus is on determining whether the statutory requirements of § 172(1), first sentence, of the BauGB are met and whether the provision is necessary and proportionate. The regulatory authority must specifically determine the composition of the resident population to be protected.

How did the district determine the composition of the resident population?

The analysis was based on a 2018 study that relied on a household survey. Of the 3,000 questionnaires distributed, only 269 valid responses were returned—mathematically, about 4.1 percent. The court deemed this sufficient because the experts had weighted the data set according to the population registry: Since participation among foreigners and Germans with a migrant background was below average, their responses were weighted more heavily, resulting in a weighted data set of approximately 525 households, or about 8 percent.

The court expressly left open the question of whether a response rate below 5 percent would generally be objectionable, because in the present case, the weighting meant that a higher rate was to be assumed in any event.

What criteria indicated potential for appreciation and the risk of displacement?

The report found that nearly 75 percent of the apartments in the area were built before 1949 and are therefore considered to have significant potential for renovation. Over 80 percent of the apartments were simply furnished, and 87 percent of the buildings did not yet have energy-efficient features. Nearly half of the housing stock was found to have high renovation potential, while another third was found to have moderate potential.

Regarding the risk of displacement, the report cited the following figures, among others: 66 percent of households consisted of foreigners or Germans with an immigrant background; 29 percent had a net income of less than 1,300 euros; and 50 percent received transfer payments such as unemployment benefits (ALG). Overall, the study classified about half of the area’s population as potentially at risk of displacement.

Is tenant protection alone sufficient grounds?

No. The court emphasizes that a preservation ordinance is not intended to fill gaps in social rental law. In the present case, however, the court found that special urban planning reasons existed: the need to adapt social infrastructure to the population, the prevention of the loss of affordable housing, and the risk of accelerated segregation processes in other neighborhoods if displaced households migrate there. In the court’s view, the fact that this indirectly results in the protection of existing tenancies does not preclude the ordinance.

How strict are the requirements for defining the area?

The court clarifies that the delineation of a conservation area is not subject to stringent requirements. The delineation falls within the municipality’s planning authority and need only ensure that the conservation objective can be achieved in substantial parts of the area. Not every individual structure within the area need be worthy of preservation.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Property Owners?

According to this ruling, anyone seeking to challenge a social preservation ordinance must specifically challenge the methodology used in the underlying study—general doubts about individual figures or the age of the expert report are not sufficient. Even a low response rate in household surveys is not problematic if it is offset by recognized statistical weighting methods. According to this ruling, the specific interests of individual property owners are examined only at the second stage of the preservation process—that is, during the respective approval process for a construction project.

Source: Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg, Judgment of June 27, 2024, Case No.: OVG 2 A 9/22

Jochen Mittenzwey
Attorney
Certified Specialist in Construction and Architectural Law
mittenzwey@mo45.de