A contractor who supplies and installs a burglar alarm and video surveillance system generally enters into a contract for work and services—not a sales contract with an obligation to install. If acceptance does not occur and the work is found to have material defects at the time a deadline is set, neither tacit nor deemed acceptance applies. The client may then validly rescind the contract without being accused of acting in bad faith or obstructing the presentation of evidence by subsequently using the system (even if only to a limited extent) or dismantling it.
What was the case about?
The defendant commissioned the plaintiff to supply and install a burglar alarm and video surveillance system for its property. This was based on a quote dated March 19, 2015; a contract for alarm system connection was subsequently added. On July 15, 2015, the plaintiff issued a final invoice in the amount of EUR 80,924.06.
In October 2015, the defendant complained of malfunctions and set a deadline for remedying the defects, which was extended until December 14, 2015. Since, in the defendant’s view, the defects had not been remedied, it declared its withdrawal from the contract in a letter dated December 23, 2015, and demanded that the plaintiff remove the equipment. It was not until July 2020, after the property had been sold, that the system was actually removed. The plaintiff continued to demand full payment for the work performed, while the defendant filed a counterclaim seeking a declaration that the contract had been converted into an obligation to return the goods.
Contract for Services or Sales Contract with Installation?
The Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf first confirms the legal classification as a contract for work and materials. According to the cited Federal Court of Justice case law, the decisive factor is whether the focus lies on the transfer of ownership and possession (in which case it is a sales contract with an obligation to install) or on the individual installation and planning services with an overarching overall result (in which case it is a contract for work and materials).
In this specific case, the customized planning of camera positions, the security concept coordinated with the police, and the separately compensated project management (approximately 2,500 EUR net) indicated a contract for work and services. It was evident that the defendant was not concerned with a specific number of devices, but rather with the result: a comprehensively monitored building. The court applies the German Civil Code (BGB) in the version in effect through December 31, 2017, to the contract concluded in 2015; the VOB/B was not validly incorporated due to the lack of sufficient opportunity to review it.
What does the ruling mean in practice?
If the interpretation of the contract indicates that the contractor/seller has undertaken to achieve a specific result and is obligated to the purchaser, the transaction is not merely a sale and delivery of the purchased item to the construction site—even if this constitutes the majority of the price in terms of value—then it constitutes a contract for work and services. In a B2B contractual relationship, the seller/contractor cannot then invoke the duty to give notice of defects under § 377 HGB to exempt itself from liability for defects, but is instead liable under the law governing contracts for work and services, subject to the associated burdens of proof and statutes of limitations.
Source: Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf, Judgment of February 19, 2026 – Case No.: 5 U 122/24
Jochen Mittenzwey
Attorney
Certified Specialist in Construction and Architectural Law
mittenzwey@mo45.de