The logo of lawyers and notaries MO45 Legal
16.
November

In its order dated October 28, 2026 (Case No. VII ZA 4/26), the Federal Court of Justice denied an application for legal aid because the intended lawsuit did not offer a reasonable prospect of success. In its reasoning, the Senate clarifies: If there is a period of one year between the personal approach to a consumer outside the business premises of the merchant and the subsequent conclusion of the contract, there is no right of rescission under the provisions governing contracts concluded outside of business premises. In such a case, the contract was no longer concluded “immediately” following the personal approach.

Key Points at a Glance

  • For a consumer's right of rescission to apply to contracts concluded outside of business premises, the contract must be concluded immediately after the consumer is personally approached.
  • If one year elapses between the personal approach and the conclusion of the contract, the Senate holds that this immediacy is lacking, and therefore the consumer has no right of rescission.

What was the case about?

With his complaint, the plaintiff sought to assert a consumer’s right of rescission under the provisions governing contracts concluded outside of business premises (Section 312b(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB)) and distance contracts (Section 312c BGB). Previously, the Regional Court of Koblenz, in its decision of January 9, 2026, and the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz, in its decision of May 15, 2026, had ruled on the matter and dismissed the action. The specific case involved a consumer contract, i.e., a contract between a business and a consumer. The offer was made to the consumer in person outside of business premises. However, the consumer did not accept this offer until one year later. The consumer believed that he had validly rescinded the contract. This turned out to be unfounded.

What rule has the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) established regarding the right of withdrawal?

The Federal Court of Justice clarifies that a consumer’s right of withdrawal does not apply to a contract concluded by means of distance communication within the meaning of Article 2(7) of Directive 2011/83/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of October 25, 2011 (Consumer Rights Directive) does not apply if there is a period of one year between the time the consumer was personally approached outside the trader’s business premises—with both parties physically present—and the actual conclusion of the contract. According to Article 2(8)(c) of the Consumer Rights Directive, a prerequisite for such a contract is that it be concluded immediately after the consumer has been personally and individually approached at a location other than the trader’s business premises. The Senate does not consider this temporal immediacy to be met when there is a one-year interval between the approach and the conclusion of the contract. Consequently, in such a case, neither the right of withdrawal under § 312b(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) nor that under § 312c BGB applies, insofar as the latter is based on this definition under EU law.

Why didn't the Federal Court of Justice refer the matter to the European Court of Justice?

Under Article 267(3) of the TFEU, courts of last instance are generally required to refer questions regarding the interpretation of Union law to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The Federal Court of Justice refrained from doing so because, in its view, the interpretation of the relevant provisions of the Consumer Rights Directive is beyond doubt. In doing so, it relies on the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, according to which a referral is unnecessary if the correct application of EU law is so obvious that there is no room for reasonable doubt (the so-called “acte clair” doctrine). In support of its reasoning, the Senate refers to decisions of the Court of Justice of the European Union dated October 15, 2024 (C-144/23), October 6, 2021 (C-561/19), and October 6, 1982 (C-283/81).

Jochen Mittenzwey
Attorney
Certified Specialist in Construction and Architectural Law
mittenzwey@mo45.de

Source: Federal Court of Justice (BGH), Order of October 28, 2026, Case No.: VII ZA 4/26